Are Air Filter Tests Representative of Indoor Particle Counts?

By Jim Rosenthal, 12/27/2011

A great deal of effort has been expended analyzing filter test results and procedures. Are these results consistent with indoor particle counts?

The ASHRAE 52.2 filter tests are designed to provide a measure of the efficiency of filters by particle size. While the MERV numbers determined by the tests give an indication of how a filter will perform on particles that reach a filter, this does not mean that these numbers will reflect particle removal efficiency in an indoor space.

Particles in an indoor space come from outdoor to indoor transfer, indoor sources and indoor air chemistry. They are removed by deposition (gravity), breathing of the individuals in the space, ventilation and particle removal devices such as a filter in an HVAC system or another air cleaning device. The efficiency of the particle removal of the filter is dependent on the efficiency of the filter, the size and aerodynamic characteristics of the particles in the space, the air changes per hour (ACH) of the HVAC system, the run time of the HVAC system and the air distribution of the HVAC system. And here is the problem, in most cases the particles in the space never reach the filter. In other cases, the particle generation factors far outweigh the ability of the removal mechanisms to reduce indoor particle concentrations. The result is that the indoor particle counts by particle size do not reflect the particle reductions found in the filter test results. They are not even close.

The prime example is what happens with particles in the 3 to 10 micrometer size range (E3) in an indoor space with alot of activity such as a school (or casino). The generation of particles by human activity overwhelms the air cleaning. This is especially true when you consider the difficulty of moving these particles to the filtration system. Their larger size means that they move slowly and often fall out of the air before they reach the filter. In fact, in most cases the majority of particles in the E3 range never reach the filter. So when you take particle counts in a space instead of having the 70% or 95% reduction we would expect based on the efficiency of the filter, we have very little reduction or at best 30-40% reduction in indoor particle counts in the 5 or 10 micrometer range.

For example, we conducted a test in a room 16 feet by 22 feet with 8 foot ceilings using a dedicated test duct. This duct was set to 2,000 cfm and contained a MERV 14 filter. The duct provided approximately 40 ACH for the room. A MERV 14 filter must have a composite minimum test result in the ASHRAE 52.2 test of between 75% and 85% efficiency in particles 0.3 to 1 micrometer, a greater than 90% efficiency on particles in the 1 to 3 micrometer size range and a 90% plus efficiency on particles between 3 and 10 micrometers. The starting baseline in the room before turning on the test duct showed particle counts of 3,564,000 in the 0.3 um range, 239,000 in the 0.5 um range, 14,170 in the 1.0 um range, 2,940 in the 2.5 um range, 880 in the 5 um range and 560 in the 10 um range. There was activity in the room with 18 people and the door was open to the rest of the office facility. After 30 minutes of operation of the test duct which gave 20 air changes in the room, the following particle counts were recorded. There were 1,800,000 particles in the 0.3 um range, 127,350 in the 0.5 um range, 8,070 in the 1 um range, 2,480 in the 2.5 um range, 860 in the 5 um range, and 530 in the 10 um range. This gave us a reduction of 49.5% in the 0.3 um range, 46.7% in the 0.5 um range, 43% in the 1 um range, 15.6% in the 2.5 um range, 2.3% in the 5 um range and 5.4% in the 10 um range. This test has been repeated several times with essentially the same results. The reductions in the particle counts in the room do not correlate with the filter particle efficiencies in the tests.

Therefore, it is important to understand that an air filter is only one component in an indoor air system. Source control, differential pressure and air distribution are equally important. If particles do not reach a filter, they cannot be removed by that filter. Claims of filter efficiency need to be viewed in this perspective.

News & Announcements

All MERV 8 Air Filters are not Created Equal - Performance Varies Greatly by Particle Size
Different MERV 8 Filters do not perform in the same way on all particle size ranges. Pleated filters have far higher efficiency on medium sized and small sized particles than polyester pads or ring panels.

Tex-Air Filters Austin Facility Grand Opening
Over 120 people attend the Grand Opening of the new Tex-Air Filters Austin Facility

Are Air Filter Tests Representative of Indoor Particle Counts?
A great deal of effort has been expended analyzing filter test results and procedures. Are these results consistent with indoor particle counts?

Tex-Air Filters Opens New Office and Warehouse in Austin
Austin Facility is conveniently located and fully stocked to supply Austin area filter customers.

Is There a Connection Between Increased Use of Central Air Conditioning and Asthma?
Has the rise in central air conditioning led to an increase in asthma in the United States or is this just a coincidence?

Study Finds HEPA Filters Reduce Cardiovascular Health Risks Associated with Air Pollution
Using HEPA filters in the home is an easy and accessible way to curb heart disease say researchers.

Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America - Texas Chapter Provides Outstanding Asthma Online Resource
Education is the key to controlling the effects of asthma. The Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America - Texas Chapter website has been enhanced to provide the best resource available on the internet for physicians, nurses, care givers, schools, asthmatics, and the parents of asthmatics.

The Effect of Particle Removal Effectiveness on Particle Levels in an Office Environment
Particle removal effectiveness is a function of filter efficiency and the air exchanges per hour but also of outdoor to indoor particle transfer, particle size and indoor activity.

Are Portable Air Purifiers Effective for Reducing Indoor Allergens?
A study by researchers at Johns Hopkins provides some interesting insight into the use of air purifiers at reducing indoor allergens.

Children in Neighborhoods Near Highways and Railroad Intersections at Risk for Asthma
A study by Mayo Clinic shows that children living near traffic intersections at greater risk of developing asthma.

Study of Particle Counts in School with Mechanical Ventilation Produces Surprising Results
This study shows that a school with mechanical ventilation and a variable volume make-up air system using MERV 8 pleated filters has significant reductions in small particles but lower than expected reductions in particles in the 3 to 10 micrometer range.

Tex-Air Filters Purchases Pure Air Filter Company of Dallas
The New Location of Tex-Air Filters at 2324 Merrell in Dallas Gives More Convenient Service to Metroplex Customers. Pictured above left to right are Benny Aycoth, Dallas Regional Manager, Stevan Brown, President and Jim Rosenthal, Chairman

Do Some Air Filter Materials React With Ozone to Create Building Related Symptoms (BRS)?
Does a Recent Analysis of BASE Data Really Show a Connection Between Synthetic Air Filters and (BRS) or Sick Building Syndrome?

Researchers Confirm Some Air Cleaners Generate Ultrafine Particles
A University of Texas Study confirms that some air cleaners actually increase ultrafine particles and formaldehyde.

Comparative Tests on Pressure Drop of HVAC Filters
We test 20 filters for pressure drop and efficiency.

Saline Rinse May Cut Cold and Flu Symptoms
Cold medications are out for children. Simple saline rinse could be the answer for quicker recovery from colds and flu.

Sorting Fact from Fiction on Health Effects of Mould
Leading Asthma and Allergy Experts Discuss the Most Recent Scientific Evidence on Health Effects of Mould

What is a Safe Level of Ozone for an Air Cleaner?
The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) is trying to answer this question. Their study and the responses to that study highlight the complexity of the issue.

Study on Photocatalytic Oxidation (PCO) Raises Questions About Formaldehyde as a Byproduct in Indoor Air
Research at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory finds that Photocatalytic Oxidation (PCO) reduces indoor VOC's but could produce formaldehyde as a byproduct.

Study Finds RCI Devices Increase Indoor Ozone and Are Relatively Ineffective at Particle Removal
This study shows that the RCI (radiant catalytic ionization) Air Cleaning Devices produce fairly significant levels of ozone and are less effective than a standard air filter at removing 2 micron sized particles.

Improving Indoor Air Quality in Classrooms Leads to Higher Test Scores
This study shows that improved indoor air quality in classrooms leads to higher test scores for students.

Study Shows Increased Inflammation in Asthmatics Exposed to Air Pollution
Fine particles in air pollution shown to increase nasal inflammation in asthmatic children.

Studies Show Improved IAQ Leads to More Productivity
Numerous studies show that improving the Indoor Air Quality will lead to higher worker productivity. Measures to improve IAQ don't cost - they pay!!

The Indoor Air Thickens - New Study Confirms Links with Ozone, Cleaning Agents and Air Contaminants
Fine particles, formaldehyde and other air contaminants are created when common cleaning agents are exposed to indoor ozone.

Isn't it Ionic? Air Purifiers Make Smog
Another study confirms that ionizers and ozone generators can create unhealthy levels of ozone in poorly ventilated rooms.

Do Air Filters Provide Health Benefits?
Air cleaners and air filters alone have not been shown to be clinically effective at reducing allergy symptoms.

Alchemy, Indoor Air and the Black Box
Be wary of excessive marketing claims for products to take care of indoor air.

Free Radicals Are NOT "Friendly Oxidizers"
Some new air cleaning devices are using free radicals or Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) to "oxidize" indoor air. Free radicals have been shown to be damaging to human health. Testing is lacking on the by-products of the reactions between free radicals and the components of indoor air.

NAFA Expands Air Filter Specialist Program
Only Filter Certification now open to all individuals interested in air filters and indoor air quality.

Avian Flu Filtration Precautions
Proper filtration can help to minimize the risk of spreading the flu virus.

Is there such a thing as Toxic Mold?
Study does not confirm "toxic mold syndrome" in patients

HEPA Air Cleaners Shown to Reduce Asthma Symptoms When Used in Conjunction with Other Control Measures
Inner City Asthma Study shows effectiveness of comprehensive environmental controls including air purifiers to control asthma.

Filter Needs in the LEED Rating System
Building owners obtain points in LEED system with proper filtration.

Proper Filter Installation Ensures Maximum Performance
Gaps between filters can cause significant decreases in filter efficiency.

Filter Efficiency and Particle Removal in Indoor Air by Particle Size
Filter tests are designed to provide filter efficiencies by particle size but they may not be good indicators for what happens in indoor air.

	Home \| Air Filtration Products \| Air Filtration Services \| Information & Articles \| About Tex-Air Filters
	Order On-line or Call Us at 1.817.261.3791

Are Air Filter Tests Representative of Indoor Particle Counts?

Order On-line or Call Us at 1.817.261.3791