• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Tex-Air Filters

Air Filter Manufacturing, Sales & Service

  • Products
  • Services
  • About
  • Articles
  • Contact
  • Cart

September 7, 2023 By Jim Rosenthal

Testing Air Filter Effectiveness at High Air Change Rates – Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes with “Used” MERV 13 Filters Can Produce Cleanroom Particle Levels

By Jim Rosenthal

In a previous article I summarized tests conducted using Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes with MERV 13 Filters at very high Air Change Rates. It was determined that two Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes could reduce particle counts in a small office to Class 10,000/ISO 7 levels in less than 15 minutes.

Could Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes Reduce Particles to “Cleanroom” Levels? – Tex-Air Filters (texairfilters.com)

Questions have been raised about the age of the filters used in the CR Boxes for these tests. Some people believe that the MERV 13 filters decrease in efficiency relatively quickly and that “used” filters would not perform at comparable levels. So we decided to repeat the tests with Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes that have been used for a considerable amount of time – one for 4 months and the other for 5 months. These units run 24/7. The 5 month old system was in an office with 2 to 3 workers. The 4 month old system was used in an employee breakroom with an entrance door opening to the outside.

Here is the 5 month old system (dirty looking filters and all).

So, let’s see what these “used” CR boxes can do. Remember, this is in a 12’X14’X8′ relatively messy office with carpeting, a drop-down ceiling, and a man (me) working at his desk without a mask. These are hardly “cleanroom” conditions! The two Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes running on the highest speed give about 40 Air Changes Per Hour (ACH).

Again, particle counts dropped dramatically and reached Class 10,000 / ISO 7 levels in less than 15 minutes. The determining numbers are: at 0.5 um less than 10,000/cubic foot and at 5 um less than 83/cubic foot. In those first 15 minutes, the 0.5 um particles had dropped from 47,800 to 6,600/cubic foot and the 5 um particles had dropped from 1,100 to 0/cubic foot. Pretty impressive!

Particle Size1:00 PM1:15 PM1:30 PM1:45 PM2:00 PM
0.3 um890,100170,700150,400141,700149,900
0.5 um47,8006,6005,8004,5005,000
1 um8,7005005000200
2.5 um3,400100000
5 um1,1000000
10 um7000000
Particles per cubic foot.

These MERV 13 filters are made with electret media. Both systems with well-used filters performed at a high level – comparable to systems using new filters. They are additional proof that filters using electret media will continue to have very high efficiency – even with prolonged use.

But, why is this important? It is important because some filter tests try to show this is not possible!

There are two major filter test standards – ASHRAE 52.2 and ISO 16890. Both incorporate test methods that are intended to decrease the electret properties of filters to simulate what could happen in use. In the case of ASHRAE 52.2, the test is called Appendix J and uses KCL particles to neutralize the electret charge on a filter. This appendix is optional and results in what is known as a MERV-A value. In my experience Appendix J tests results are not consistent and generally overstate the loss in efficiency of filters in use. For example, the MERV 13 filters used on these Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes oftentimes are found to have a MERV-A of 10. It is clear that they do not perform like MERV 10 filters – either new or used.

ISO 16890 uses a different procedure to simulate the potential loss of the electret charge of a filter. There are two tests involved. The first is of a new filter. The second incorporates Isopropyl Alcohol (IPA) vapor that “neutralizes” or eliminates the charge. (It has also been shown to damage the fibers of the media.) Then the “neutralized” filter is tested. The results of the first test with a new filter and the second test are averaged resulting in the number used to determine an ePM value. I am not aware of any research showing that these values are consistent with what happens with electret filters in use. Once again, we do not see anything close to this drop in efficiency in the MERV 13 Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes used in these tests.

Another important question has to do to the “mixing” of the air cleaning in the room. Are the air cleaners working to “mix” the air and provide consistent particle levels throughout the room? To test this we took particle counts in the corners of the room after the boxes had been in operation for 30 minutes. The boxes were in two corners of the room – 3 feet away from the walls. Measurements were taken with the particle counter 18 inches from each corner. Here are the results

Size Corner #1 – No CR BoxCorner #2 – CR BoxCorner #3 – No CR BoxCorner #4 – CR Box
0.3 um147,800136,000237,500167,000
0.5 um5,7005,3008,7006,800
1 um1,000700900300
2.5 um200200600100
5 um100000
10 um100000
Particle levels are per cubic foot.

The particle counts in all 4 corners are in the same range of a Class 10,000/ISO 7 cleanroom. The air in the room appears to be “well mixed.” I would attribute this to the design of the Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes. The air enters on the sides of the box and exits vertically from the fan on top. The air then hits the ceiling and disperses throughout the room. The result is that all areas of the space have about the same particle counts and low exposure to indoor contaminants.

There are several “take aways” from these tests. First, high air change rates can produce extremely low particle counts reinforcing the filter effectiveness formula of Filter + Fit + Flow. Second, even MERV 13 electret filters that have been in continuous use for 4 or 5 months produce the same types of positive results as new filters. Third, Corsi-Rosenthal Boxes effectively mix the air in a space to provide uniform coverage and safety.

Filed Under: Articles

Previous Post
Next Post

Primary Sidebar

Office & Factory
5933 Eden Drive
Haltom City, TX 76117

sales@allergyclean.com

817.261.3791
817.496.3430 Fax

Tex-Air Filters - Austin
2209-A Rutland Drive, Suite 150
Austin, TX 78758

512.833.3330
512.833.3335 Fax
512.415.1753 Commercial Filter Sales

Tex-Air Filters - Dallas
11251 Leo Lane
Dallas, TX 75229

972.247.7101
972.247.5178 Fax
817.408.6908 Commercial Filter Sales

Tex-Air Filters - Houston
6529 Cunningham Road, Suite #2101
Houston, TX 77041

346.409.2984
346.409.2986 Fax
580.512.1425 Commercial Filter Sales

Tex-Air Filters - San Antonio
2416 Brockton Street Suite 101
San Antonio, Texas 78217

210.290.9412
210.290.9418 Fax
210.612.8778 Commercial Filter Sales

Texas HVAC License
TACLA023325C

Texas HVAC Lic. TACLA023325C

Copyright © 2025 Tex-Air Filters · All Rights Reserved · Privacy Policy · Refunds/Exchanges